Pax Internetum Day 7 – In Defence of the Contrary.

In this last post is two days late, partly because I didn’t want to rush it out but mainly because life has interceded and taken attention away. Today, in this last post on a brief period of peace, I would like to discuss contrariness, negativity and the culture of refusal, and their immense and unrecognised value to humanity. Many of the ideas in this post might come as a small shock to less-travelled American and Australian readers who are not accustomed to the British manner of parsing disaster, of holding out a tarpaulin to plummeting morale and yanking it away at the last minute just for a laugh

As I was walking down the street one day
I saw a house on fire
There was man, shouting and screaming at an upper-storey window
To the crowd that was gathered there below
For he was so afraid

Jump, you fucker, jump.
Jump into this here blanket what we are holding
And you will be all right
He jumped, hit the deck, broke his fucking neck –
There was no blanket

Laugh? We nearly shat.
We had not laughed so much since Grandma died
Or Auntie Mabel caught her left tit in the mangle
We are miserable sinners
Fi-i-ilthy fuckers


–Derek and Clive, Live, 1976

As the American tendency to amiability and good cheer spreads through that part of society that benefits from the pretence that everything is always for the best and that all it takes to live a happy life is a smile and a ‘can-do’ attitude (a phrase which should earn any non-ironic employer of it a stint in a re-education facility and twenty years suspended upside down in salt and scorpions) spreads through the world, carried on the back of globalised TV, those who are minded to look will see value in the contrary and the negative. Culture and public life over the last 10 years has been so anodyne, so glued to the search for superficial consensus, so firmly fixed to action – or inaction –  without rocking the boat that we forget that there was a time when mainstream politicians stood up for their principles rather than submerging them in a warm bath of populist politics until they emerged, drowned and bedraggled and unrecognisable, useful only for cattle feed. It is this sort of damp and warm environment in which fiery and passionate leaders germinate.

Europe has been here before, of course, most recently during the interbellum period. This tranche of European history is one that half of Europe wants to forget and the other half desperately wants to keep alive. It was a time of economic hardship, when the financial misfortunes of one country could be traced directly to the actions of another. France’s war reparations were so unreasonable, deliberately,  as  a means of seizing the German industrial heartlands which were forfeit to France when Germany could no longer pay. By 1923, Germany was bankrupt and a sinister political movement was well on the way to seizing power in Europe.

I know. This hardly sounds like an argument in favour of adversity, but the crucial point is that the Nazis – in common with all totalitarian movements –  pursued a strategy of imposing order on the chaos of the time, and of imposing consent where there was dissent. In fact, they knew as well as any illegitimate authority that the most effective tactic was to move hard and publicly against those who dissent only weakly and who have no power in order to discourage the power bases of stronger opposition.

It’s startlingly similar to what we see at the moment. Argument has never been more political, the stakes never higher.

So this is a post for all those who are tired of the cosy cohabitation between powerful financial interests and politicians, of this idle assumed consensus foisted on us by politicians, newspaper editors, TV companies and employers. This is a post for those who know that the free market is just another human construct, no more fundamental than taxes or justice, and that humans can change it if we really want to. It’s for people who know that power should never be trusted, truth should never be assumed and authority should always be challenged.

It’s a message to the contrary.

5 thoughts on “Pax Internetum Day 7 – In Defence of the Contrary.

  1. Shon says:

    Writing from Aus’ , and agree with your sentiments strongly. I have a degree from uni but have been a stockman for most of my working life (20 years), but have had to leave all that behind and over the last 12 months I’ve really learnt what is going on with world. I have just been accepted to an international seminar in Aus for nonviolent civil resistence as I hope to gain an understanding of the ways to stop this onslaught of TPTB. It may be a hopeless struggle, but when you realise the destructive path most govt’s/transnational corps are taking us, you know you have to stand up. I have always had healthy skepticism, but have not ever been a conspiratorialist – or a redneck! However, it seems there is just too much evidence now that we are ALL in a very serious situation and that the time to step up to the next level of conciousness has arrived.
    Good on you for having the skill and the impetus to write what you do.
    See you when we get there, if we ever get there.

    • kargosh says:

      Unfortunately, I suspect that the result of all this will be the collapse of democracy. We see power flowing away from democratic institutions and towards unaccountable bodies. Look at the last few months in Europe: Merkel effectively ordering Greece to surrender national sovereignty, technocratic dictators (some with actual fascist backgrounds) installed in Italy and Greece and the interests of entire nations sacrificed for bondholder profit. As China’s and India’s (for India is a democracy in theory, but not in practice) influence deepens, it can only get worse.

      It seems that the West’s past and future has been sold for a few million boomer pensions.

  2. Damocles says:

    Everyone anyone seems to disagree with is the Nazis. The left wing are Nazis according to the right and the right are according to the left.


    Face life with a smile on your lips and a song in your heart and you may not have the greatest life but at least it’ll be better than the idiot wandering around accusing everyone who disagrees with him of being a Nazi.

  3. kargosh says:

    That’s a very unusual false opposition you’ve set up there. Walk around smiling like an idiot while you’re being mugged for your birthright or go around telling everyone they’re Nazis?

    Which sixth-form common room is this again?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s